This dissonance has been, and (it seems) will always be, the primary stumbling block in the discussion of the information economy.
Why are pirates immoral? Why are they not immoral? Why is DRM immoral? Why is DRM not immoral? Who owns the copyright? what is fair use?
All to do with information. All fighting this central dissonance.
This is why the Patreon model should be advocated when it comes to information. Because as a tool, the market is utterly unfit to operate in this arena.