undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmunin9y ago0 comments

> you can simply emit non-ssa form and QBE will fixup things for you

That's exactly what LLVM does though, except the "non-SSA form" involves loads/stores to alloca'd values. The difference is that in LLVM, the language is always in SSA form, it just has some reads / writes to memory that can be pruned, while QBE alternates between being an SSA language and not an SSA language.

LLVM also doesn't "make" you use stack slots. If you wanted to, you could emit fully pruned programs as LLVM IR. Using allocas for variables is a choice that clang makes.

0 comments

mpu9y ago

I think the extra load/stores clutter the IL.

Also, QBE does not really "alternate" SSA/non-SSA, SSA form is built once at the beginning of the compilation pipeline and preserved later.

I don't understand what you mean by "fully pruned programs". Maybe you want to refer to pruned SSA form. And then, here is my point: with LLVM, either you build SSA yourself or you use allocas. QBE offers a convenient third option.

sklogic9y ago

Some CFG transforms are actually much easier if you get out of an SSA first, reshuffle CFG without caring about maintaining your phis, and then simply rebuild an SSA form.

nickpsecurity9y ago

Expected to see you here. Hey, send me an email or something so I can send you interesting stuff without hunting your profile or random comments on HN. Address in my profile. Here's the one I was saving for you to complement the ML and Haskell CPU's I linked.

https://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/bam_jlp.ps

Cool stuff, eh? That they keep it close to a regular, RISC processor means optimizations of that should carry over. Unlike stuff like Fifth Generation that tried to go way, way the hell to far with Prolog hardware. ;) Should fit nicely into my concept of general-purpose CPU's with purpose-built coprocessors. Also speculate techniques might be helpful on ASIC's meant for today's big-data apps that use things like Datalog for queries. Ya think?

riscy9y ago

> I don't understand what you mean by "fully pruned programs". Maybe you want to refer to pruned SSA form.

The mem2reg pass in LLVM is the recommended method of constructing pruned SSA form. It just implements the standard algorithm.

> QBE does not really "alternate" SSA/non-SSA, SSA form is built once at the beginning of the compilation pipeline and preserved later.

The QBE IL presented to the user is not in SSA form, but internally within your compiler, an SSA representation is kept. I prefer to not have syntactic sugar in my IL.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse