undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmegakwood10y ago0 comments

> The point is that if the HSR people can't get something done for $X, it's unlikely that Musk can do something even more ambitious for $X/10

IDK, indeed $X/10 is ambitious but he does have a decent track record with this already. SpaceX is already $X/3 or $X/4 and is on the path to $X/10 with reusable rockets, and it's also more ambitious (rocket reuse, highest payload in the world by 2x, new capsule has powered rocket landing on any surface in the solar system).

In my mind he's earned some benefit of the doubt. Of course, there's still a ton to prove, and the idea sounds looney. You'd also have said that about SpaceX 10 years ago, though.

0 comments

tptacek10y ago

Can he make my car get 10X the mileage first? Or my wireless have 10X the range? Argumentum ad Musk doesn't seem like a particularly powerful way to make a point.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

tptacek10y ago

Can he make my car get 10X the mileage first? Or my wireless have 10X the range? Argumentum ad Musk doesn't seem like a particularly powerful way to make a point.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse