undefined | Better HN

0 pointsthomasfoster969y ago0 comments

For starters the speaker and deputy speaker of each chamber are listed as being not being in their own parties, which isn't true (although it is in the U.K.), instead they have strange abbreviations for the name of the position.

Secondly, in Australia the Liberal National Party is a partial merger of the Liberal and National parties. MPs in the LNP can be a member of either the Liberals or Nationals. In the House of Representatives data for Australia, the breakdown of LNP MPs between the two parties is incorrect, and leaves one MP as a sole member of the LNP. The errors are similar in the Senate data.

Additionally, two politicians (Bob Katter and Jacqui Lambie) are wrongly shown as being independents, despite being elected as the sole member of a party.

0 comments

everypolitician9y ago

Thanks! I've checked in case any of this is our screwup with how we're importing the data, but it turns out that all of these are like this in our source (http://data.openaustralia.org/members/representatives.xml), which is going to make it a little tricky to unpack. I'll talk to the guys from OpenAustralia next week when everyone's back at work and see if we can get them to fix these upstream, otherwise we'll look into ways of working around them.

With the Liberal National Party is this a distinction between the electoral party and the parliamentary party? i.e. do people stand for election as one of Liberal or National, but then sit in a group as a single Liberal National Party? Or do they each sit as members of distinct parties which are, in turn, in coalition?

Or, from another angle, what would you expect to see within our data: a combined "Liberal National Party" for each person (with a separate field to show which party they stood for election as), or individual "Liberal Party" and "National Party" affiliations at the MP level, with the coalition shown at a party/term level?

thomasfoster96OP9y ago

The Liberal National Party is electoral only at the national level, but parliamentary at the state level (Queensland). In the other states the Liberals and Nationals are only in an electoral alliance and parliamentary coalition, and haven't actually merged, so LNP politicians are split into the Liberal and National parties. The Country Liberal Party is similar to the LNP, but it only operates in the Northern Territory and its only Senator sits with the Nationals.

Wikipedia shows LNP MPs as being a part of the LNP, with a note stating their affiliation.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse