undefined | Better HN

0 pointsWayneBro9y ago0 comments

Incorrect. "Science" is the reason why we had things like lobotomies in the first place.

Your entire arguments rests on a "No true Scotsman"-like logical fallacy.

0 comments

I'll reiterate my point: science is not immune from mistakes (nobody is arguing that), but in general, it tends to correct those mistakes over time.

There is no science without people though...and people are not immune from mistakes.

j2kun9y ago

Nobody is saying they are, which is my entire point

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsWayneBro9y ago0 comments

Incorrect. "Science" is the reason why we had things like lobotomies in the first place.

Your entire arguments rests on a "No true Scotsman"-like logical fallacy.

j2kun9y ago

I'll reiterate my point: science is not immune from mistakes (nobody is arguing that), but in general, it tends to correct those mistakes over time.

There is no science without people though...and people are not immune from mistakes.

j2kun9y ago

Nobody is saying they are, which is my entire point

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse