undefined | Better HN

0 pointshelge59y ago0 comments

You pay personal taxes on your personal income (the salary the company may give you). That is completely distinct to the type of the company discussed in the link, a GmbH/UG. A company construct like that is its own legal person and it pays its own taxes (which usually works different to your 'personal taxes'). Where it has to pay them is a question for your tax accountant, I think (ignoring loopholes) a company producing income in Germany has to pay taxes on that in Germany, regardless where the company is registered. Though especially with IT it is sometimes hard to specify the 'where' :-) But trust me, the tax authorities will know :-)

What you can gain by filing your company in Estonia is less bureaucracy. The talk is that Estonia is a lot in e-government, so I suppose that means you can do a lot of filing stuff very conveniently on the Internet. Or if you employ people in Estonia, the employment laws may be less strict than in a country like Germany.

If you plan to operate out of Germany, I don't think you'll gain much by registering a company in Estonia. If you want to move to and operate in Estonia, it may be well worth a consideration.

As mentioned, in the past people filed companies in the UK to avoid the 25000 Euro investment required for a GmbH. But that's gone with the UG.

0 comments

sparkling9y ago

Just to clarify, as long as all the money remains in the Estonian company entity (e.g. you are not paying yourself a salary), you should not owe any personal income tax in Germany since their is no income, correct?

helge5OP9y ago

If you have no personal income from a company (profits or salary) you do not owe personal income taxes - wherever. No personal income, no personal income taxes. That seems kinda obvious :-)

However, the company itself very likely has to pay German company taxes and need German business permits if you operate from Germany / generate the income in Germany.

But if you have 10 Estonian developers in your Estonian company doing programming for you in Estonia and you are only the founder/investor living in Germany, you probably wouldn't have to pay anything in Germany if you don't pay out profits.

To get a dependable answer you really have to discuss that with a tax lawyer. And finding one which can deal with multinational businesses is going to be really tough and presumably expensive. Which is another reason why this whole thing is more headache than gain, IMO.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse