I've got more icons in my bar than you've got on your website. You could just scan a few "favourite menulet" pages[0] to bulk add stuff, should take a small amount of time.
Here's some content for you http://snpy.in/nNlirJ in order: Caffeine, DragonDrop, Keyboard Maestro, 1Password, Hazel, Snappy, DayOne, aText, f.lux, Dropbox, Mail Notifr and then the standard OS ones.
You can probably find 100 more just on first page of google.
Maybe changing your site to something like "menulet database.com" and collect them like that would have a stronger audience though (I know I'd be first i line).
[0] There used to be blogs dedicated to this very thing in the past.