undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmundanevoice8y ago0 comments

You do understand that it doesn't only rely on fingerprints, right? There is retinal verification in addition to phone OTP. I had another phone number when I got Aadhar, I changed the city, lost my phone number and now there is no way, I can without physically getting somewhere and submitting the application to update my phone number.

API for commercial services isn't a bad thing per se. A lot of time, it would save time in documentation. Btw, if you have such a privacy concern, Are you not using Facebook, Whatsapp and all other services for free that sell you data, you behaviour to commercial companies.

It's really easy to believe the FUD going on and coming up some original ideas on how to tackle the problem. I hope you are in the second group that would help make our Country a better place to live in.

0 comments

ganduG8y ago

But using Facebook and other websites is a choice. Using Aadhar is not a choice - its mandatory.

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

How do you suggest in a country of fucking Billion people you would get people to use something? 40% people don't understand shit, doesn't care about privacy, they want food on their table, they want to get the money they rightfully earn. These people are less fortunate than many of us. With Aadhar and Household gas linked, they get the subsidy rightly in their bank account without paying every fucking agent that would loot them at any possible point.

I agree, making it mandatory for "Income Tax" is bit controversial. But even you also know how many people in India, rightfully pay taxes. The percentage is pretty damn low.

And frankly using Facebook and Twitter is not really a choice. It's a result of being Socially coerced into being on one of the platforms to not feel left out. And anyone who talks about privacy and openness would never be on either of these two if he really knows what he talks about.

mindentropy8y ago

Just a question to you. I can understand the problems faced by bribery and it being eradicated but how according to your argument can the person who is illiterate understand about privacy or for that matter things he/she is not expert in? To elaborate it is not the responsibility of the illiterates or the people who are not knowledgeable to worry about the privacy. Instead it is the responsibility of the people implementing the system to make sure that all security and privacy is implemented and also the laws to be introduced to protect the common man.

This is the very reason the government has think tanks and expert advisors. It seems all these people have failed. When the system fails completely then again it is these same poor common man who will face the brunt presently seen or unseen.

captn3m08y ago

Just from last week: CCC managed to break IRIS recognition system by holding a printout of a HD photo in front of a camera.

[0]: https://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2017/iriden

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

Yes, I am aware. But this hack didn't existed when Aadhar was provisioned, and many institutions in the world use Iris recognition. Does this mean everyone in the world will stop using Iris recognition or push a patch to fix the vulnerability?

xeronkek8y ago

>API for commercial services isn't a bad thing per se. A lot of time, it would save time in documentation. Btw, if you have such a privacy concern, Are you not using Facebook, Whatsapp and all other services for free that sell you data, you behaviour to commercial companies.

So you mean to say that its cool to leak my whole family tree data along with AADHAR and PHONE NUMBER to the public? So a novice can know about my sister via Dark net and can use that piece of information?

>Implying I am using Facebook. >Implying Zuck is forcing you to hand out your fingerprints and shit for better services. >Implying you can't get SIM without having a Facebook ID.

>I hope you are in the second group that would help make our Country a better place to live in.

Tell me one way AADHAR is making this country a better place and I will counter that challenge without implementing AADHAR.

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

1) There is no real reliable proof of a leak yet. 2) Remember all your fancy iPhones, Macbooks and Pixel etc. having fingerprint sensors. You 100% sure none of these would/could be leaked. Why the hypocritical attack on just one thing?

Out of various things, just one thing: My maid got her account opened for free due to Jan Dhan scheme. The only document required was Aadhar which she had due to a massive drive to enrol people in Aadhar. Now, She got a gas connection without much fuss and all the govt. subsidy gets directly deposited to her bank account. I too give her monthly due via NEFT. All her money goes directly to the deserving place without ever bribing anyone. If it's not making this country a better place for these people, I don't now what is?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

ganduG8y ago

But using Facebook and other websites is a choice. Using Aadhar is not a choice - its mandatory.

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

I agree, making it mandatory for "Income Tax" is bit controversial. But even you also know how many people in India, rightfully pay taxes. The percentage is pretty damn low.

mindentropy8y ago

captn3m08y ago

Just from last week: CCC managed to break IRIS recognition system by holding a printout of a HD photo in front of a camera.

[0]: https://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2017/iriden

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

xeronkek8y ago

>Implying I am using Facebook. >Implying Zuck is forcing you to hand out your fingerprints and shit for better services. >Implying you can't get SIM without having a Facebook ID.

>I hope you are in the second group that would help make our Country a better place to live in.

Tell me one way AADHAR is making this country a better place and I will counter that challenge without implementing AADHAR.

mundanevoiceOP8y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse