undefined | Better HN

0 pointsNicolaiS8y ago0 comments

The 't' vs 'T' has _nothing_ to do with checksums.

`Transfer` and `transfer` are two different functions, one creating an "event" (think a signal on the blockchain) and the other actually transfering tokens.

The true flaw lies in the reentrant attack on `.send()`

0 comments

kefka8y ago

My comment on checksums was a overall comment of shoddy and embarrassing hacked crap they call Ethereum.

They claimed again and again that the code is the contract and vice versa. That was proven not true by the VIP() function.

And seriously, if this protocol was given proper due diligence, there would be no reentrant attack on this. But that points back to amateur hour. And a lot of people here have money in ETH and can't come to understand this due to the extreme cognitive dissonance.

(The premise of Ethereum really is amazing. Too bad it wasn't given the same diligence as Satoshi gave it.)

Laaas8y ago

jesus christ, who the fuck would make two identical symbols differentiated by only capitalisation? (Other than these guys obviously)

pjc508y ago

It's surprising that most languages will happily let you do this. Lots of C programs have 'FOO' and 'foo'; not so many will have 'Foo' as well but it's probably more common than you think.

Laaas8y ago

IMO this is only a problem if they both are the same type, e.g. both are a function, both are a type, both are a variable, both are a special keyword, things like that, because then it's hard to mix them up. If however you can substitute one for the other in code and still have it compile, that would be terrible.

codedokode8y ago

It is humans' fault that they cannot choose good name for function, not languages'.

lproven8y ago

What, you mean apart from every Unix ever?

(All right, all right, excluding Mac OS X. But it's weird.)

jchw8y ago

That's filesystems, not the OS. There are some extremely good reasons to treat filenames as bags of bytes, which is why Apple got rid of case folding in APFS. Think performance, locale issues, etc.

(And before someone says it, yes, of course performance matters for filenames. Every single stat shouldn't need to worry about case folding.)

1 more reply

kbody8y ago

There's a big difference between being and actually making use of such anti-patterns. Especially on such a scale.

0x08y ago

You can have macOS use case sensitive filesystems (like case sensitive HFS+), and you can have linux use a case insensitive file system (like FAT32)

kerkeslager8y ago

I believe you, but this doesn't persuade me that Ethereum isn't "pure amateur hour".

bpicolo8y ago

To be fair, bad naming choice

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

kefka8y ago

My comment on checksums was a overall comment of shoddy and embarrassing hacked crap they call Ethereum.

They claimed again and again that the code is the contract and vice versa. That was proven not true by the VIP() function.

(The premise of Ethereum really is amazing. Too bad it wasn't given the same diligence as Satoshi gave it.)

Laaas8y ago

jesus christ, who the fuck would make two identical symbols differentiated by only capitalisation? (Other than these guys obviously)

pjc508y ago

It's surprising that most languages will happily let you do this. Lots of C programs have 'FOO' and 'foo'; not so many will have 'Foo' as well but it's probably more common than you think.

Laaas8y ago

codedokode8y ago

It is humans' fault that they cannot choose good name for function, not languages'.

lproven8y ago

What, you mean apart from every Unix ever?

(All right, all right, excluding Mac OS X. But it's weird.)

jchw8y ago

That's filesystems, not the OS. There are some extremely good reasons to treat filenames as bags of bytes, which is why Apple got rid of case folding in APFS. Think performance, locale issues, etc.

(And before someone says it, yes, of course performance matters for filenames. Every single stat shouldn't need to worry about case folding.)

1 more reply

kbody8y ago

There's a big difference between being and actually making use of such anti-patterns. Especially on such a scale.

0x08y ago

You can have macOS use case sensitive filesystems (like case sensitive HFS+), and you can have linux use a case insensitive file system (like FAT32)

kerkeslager8y ago

I believe you, but this doesn't persuade me that Ethereum isn't "pure amateur hour".

bpicolo8y ago

To be fair, bad naming choice

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse