Ask HN: Are companies blowing off the terms of the AGPL?

1 pointscilantro15y ago1 comments

I've been perplexed for a while about this. It seems like many people are either unaware of how restrictive this license is, or are choosing to disregard it. For example, I find it hard to believe that all the projects leveraging MongoDB I see posted to HN are GPL-ing their code or buying a commercial license.

What am I missing? I sincerely don't understand.

1 comments

stevenwei15y ago

Well at least for MongoDB the reason is quite clear. From their licensing page (http://www.mongodb.org/display/DOCS/Licensing):

   Note however that it is never required that applications using mongo be published.
   The copyleft applies only to the mongod and mongos database programs. This is why
   Mongo DB drivers are all licensed under an Apache license. Your application, even
   though it talks to the database, is a separate program and “work”.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

Ask HN: Are companies blowing off the terms of the AGPL?

1 pointscilantro15y ago1 comments

What am I missing? I sincerely don't understand.

1 comments

stevenwei15y ago

Well at least for MongoDB the reason is quite clear. From their licensing page (http://www.mongodb.org/display/DOCS/Licensing):

   Note however that it is never required that applications using mongo be published.
   The copyleft applies only to the mongod and mongos database programs. This is why
   Mongo DB drivers are all licensed under an Apache license. Your application, even
   though it talks to the database, is a separate program and “work”.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse