undefined | Better HN

0 pointsericpauley7y ago0 comments

Keep in mind that capacitance and capacity are not the same. Case in point, the capacitor mentioned can hold a peak voltage of 24kV, which is allows for a million times more energy to be stored than the same capacitance at 24V peak. Capacitors with far lower peak voltages can have capacitance exceeding several Farads.

0 comments

bovine3dom7y ago

Yeah, I was taking some liberties with the definition of largest.

They're still a ridiculously big unit though. Generally the biggest man-made structures on Earth are measured in mega*. Single digits are usually used for things that are roughly apple-sized.

photojosh7y ago

But in electricity/electronics, we deal with the entire range of metric prefixes… terabytes, nanofarads, gigaohms, microseconds.

I'm curious as to what you mean by "biggest man-made structures" though. For me that brings to mind tall buildings, long walls and big dams. I suppose that the Great Wall is 20 "megametres" long, but normally long dimensions will be in kilometres, heights are in 100s of metres and dams are in billions of cubic metres. Care to share some examples?

bovine3dom7y ago

> But in electricity/electronics, we deal with the entire range of metric prefixes… terabytes, nanofarads, gigaohms, microseconds

But you don't. You'll almost never use whole Farads, for example. It's even on the Wikipedia page: related units, nF, uF.

> Care to share some examples?

I don't really mind the difference between giga/mega/kilo. I was really just talking about a ballpark where we don't want the biggest thing ever to be unity in our everyday unit.

You do raise a valid point with height. This is because the gravitational field in some sense makes length directional: 3km up is very different to 3km along. Clearly, we need some vector based measures so we could scale them sensibly, g-hat and x-hat : ).

Can you think of many man made structures who have just one of some extensive property in an everyday unit?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

bovine3dom7y ago

Yeah, I was taking some liberties with the definition of largest.

They're still a ridiculously big unit though. Generally the biggest man-made structures on Earth are measured in mega*. Single digits are usually used for things that are roughly apple-sized.

photojosh7y ago

But in electricity/electronics, we deal with the entire range of metric prefixes… terabytes, nanofarads, gigaohms, microseconds.

bovine3dom7y ago

> But in electricity/electronics, we deal with the entire range of metric prefixes… terabytes, nanofarads, gigaohms, microseconds

But you don't. You'll almost never use whole Farads, for example. It's even on the Wikipedia page: related units, nF, uF.

> Care to share some examples?

I don't really mind the difference between giga/mega/kilo. I was really just talking about a ballpark where we don't want the biggest thing ever to be unity in our everyday unit.

Can you think of many man made structures who have just one of some extensive property in an everyday unit?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse