undefined | Better HN

0 pointskstrauser7y ago0 comments

Of course they’re entitled, but I’m also entitled to say I think this move was either idiotic or malevolent.

I’m unsympathetic to the “oh no the cloud” mindset. I’ve worked at companies that have made on-premise patches to FOSS since the 90s. Can you imagine if Linux required you to make the source available of all software you ran on it? Or MySQL? Or Perl/PHP? I can vaguely see the point of the AGPL for things like web front end stuff where there’s a blurry line between you visitor merely visiting your site and you distributing the software to them. But that’s just madness for infrastructure code.

And I’ll bet that the MongoDB team has used lots of FOSS that they didn’t financially support, so I see it as whining when they complain about others doing the same.

0 comments

simias7y ago

You use their code for free and call them "idiotic or malevolent" when they make it harder for you to use their code for free. I can completely understand the frustration of their users if this move makes their life harder but it's still pretty entitled of you to insult them because they changed the license to something you don't like.

It's perfectly understandable if you decide not to use their software because you find their license unacceptable but don't insult them for doing what they want with their own project. If a sizeable enough number of contributors are unhappy with the move they're still free to fork and continue the previous version of Mongo DB with the old license.

kstrauserOP7y ago

There is a decent chance that they’re using code I’ve written, and I haven’t seen a penny from them. Have you? Has anyone?

I think it’s either:

- Idiotic, because they meant well but managed to shoot themselves in the foot by making their software unviable, or

- Malevolent, because they’re using this as a wedge to either force you into a pay-or-lose-it situation, while still trying to paint themselves as FOSS.

toomuchtodo7y ago

Because you don’t feel others are freeloading on you does not mean software consumers aren’t freeloading.

You’re free to change your licenses (or not), just as other projects are (but should).

It’s time the free ride and expectations of charity by for-profit users ends.

1 more reply

gaius7y ago

You use their code for free and call them "idiotic or malevolent" when they make it harder for you to use their code for free.

MongoDB is little more than mmap() attached to a socket. They would be nowhere without piggybacking on a million lines of other people’s free code.

fwiw17y ago

MongoDB uses WiredTiger storage engine currently. mmap storage engine is all but deprecated.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse