undefined | Better HN

0 pointsHari_Seldon15y ago0 comments

I disagree that Apple have a low-risk strategy, remember the iPod mini? this thing was wildly successful and yet Apple killed it and replaced it with the nano. I can't think of another company that would take that kind of risk.

And although it may not seem so today - launching a glass-fronted phone with a single button, was seen by many to be completely nuts.

0 comments

JeremyBanks15y ago

I think that sounds rather more significant than it was. The Nano was very much a natural successor to the Mini, I don't think there was any doubt that it would be at least as successful.

wvenable15y ago

Learning that people like small iPods and making an even smaller iPod is not risky -- that's just common sense.

Touch-screen phones in almost the same configuration as the iPhone existed years before it's release. There was really nothing nuts about making improvements to that design. Even if there was no guarantee that the iPhone would be wildly successful, it was certainly not going to be a total failure.

ams611015y ago

I don't know, I think the new nano is too small. Apple did a good job with the UI-on-a-postage-stamp, but the thing is just physically too small to hold and use with one hand. If the body were a bit longer so you could hold it with your fingers and use your thumb to navigate, that would be better. IMHO.

wvenable15y ago

Apple does make mistakes -- the buttonless shuffle was universally panned and now the new one has buttons again. If the new nano is too small, the next nano will be bigger. But, getting back to the original point, these product changes are purely evolutionary.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsHari_Seldon15y ago0 comments

And although it may not seem so today - launching a glass-fronted phone with a single button, was seen by many to be completely nuts.

0 comments

JeremyBanks15y ago

I think that sounds rather more significant than it was. The Nano was very much a natural successor to the Mini, I don't think there was any doubt that it would be at least as successful.

wvenable15y ago

Learning that people like small iPods and making an even smaller iPod is not risky -- that's just common sense.

ams611015y ago

wvenable15y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse