undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdcosson6y ago0 comments

None of the “well actually” replies you’re getting has yet mentioned that carrying forward personal capital losses is capped at $3000 per year. How could anyone argue that is remotely the same as Amazon avoiding billions in taxes?

There are also a lot of other ways companies get much more favorable tax treatment than people — for one thing just very fundamentally, they are taxed on profits but people are taxed on revenues, with no ability to deduct most major costs like paying rent or healthcare bills below a very high cutoff.

Kind of a tangent here but I can’t help thinking about this discrepancy when I hear about ISAs, and how people should be able to use the funding methods that companies do like selling shares in themselves. You can be a company but without any of the favorable treatment!

0 comments

bryanlarsen6y ago

In theory, that's what the standard deduction is for. If you spend $1MM/month on rent, that's a luxury and should use after-tax dollars. If you spend $500, that's a necessity and should use before-tax dollars. Thus the 12,000 standard deduction: the first $1000/month you spend on rent, food etc is done with before-tax dollars, subsequent dollars use after-tax dollars.

TheCoelacanth6y ago

Businesses get to deduct their actual expenses, though, not just their minimal subsistence-level expenses.

dcossonOP6y ago

I'm taxed on my actual income though, not something like the whole country's median income. But I can only deduct a crude approximation of the whole country's minimum necessary expenses.

It definitely works against you both ways in high COL areas, where salaries are higher in part bc expenses are higher, but deductions are still fixed.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse