What is your rationale? Netflix suspends your account for non-payment, the same should apply to web infrastructure.
Can you program in some code to display on the website “this website owner needs to pay for their site” etc.
and if they don’t pay you, you don’t disable it. And it activates after a while. Plus it would have redundant things so they can’t easily just hire one guy to remove it.
Or it could be some thing that breaks the site in a less obvious way and they call you to fix it.
It doesn’t seem to break any laws that I know of. Do you?