undefined | Better HN

0 pointscutler6y ago0 comments

Even if GraalVM fixes startup times aren't JVM languages just too long-winded for scripting? Perl, Python and Ruby dominate the scripting world for a reason - standard libraries for file, dir and pathname manipulation written in a concise language. Scripting is a style of coding, not just a means to an end. It is here that dynamic languages excel. Clojure is the leanest of the JVMs but doesn't it still rely on Java for file, dir and pathname manipulation?

0 comments

dragonwriter6y ago

> Even if GraalVM fixes startup times aren't JVM languages just too long-winded for scripting? Perl, Python and Ruby dominate the scripting world for a reason

Ruby is a JVM language, in that JRuby is a very complete competitive, current, and widely-used-in-production Ruby implementation.

cutlerOP6y ago

By JVM languages I really meant those designed originally for the JVM, ie. Java, Clojure, Scala, Kotlin & Groovy.

dragonwriter6y ago

Even so, Clojure and Groovy aren't particularly long-winded, nor is Scala despite static typing.

zmmmmm6y ago

You should definitely educate yourself about Groovy. It's my favorite scripting language, particularly because it enables a true scripting style, but actually works well as a full application development language too (though I would always want a backbone of static typed code).

slifin6y ago

It relies on the implementation of its runtime, JVM, .net, JavaScript, BeamVM etc but uses it's own language for those operations, slurp/barf etc

So as a developer it's all the same until you start leveraging the features of your particular runtime but this does make code sharing viable

davidw6y ago

There are JVM versions of Python, Ruby and Tcl, so it's not really about the VM itself.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointscutler6y ago0 comments

0 comments

dragonwriter6y ago

> Even if GraalVM fixes startup times aren't JVM languages just too long-winded for scripting? Perl, Python and Ruby dominate the scripting world for a reason

Ruby is a JVM language, in that JRuby is a very complete competitive, current, and widely-used-in-production Ruby implementation.

cutlerOP6y ago

By JVM languages I really meant those designed originally for the JVM, ie. Java, Clojure, Scala, Kotlin & Groovy.

dragonwriter6y ago

Even so, Clojure and Groovy aren't particularly long-winded, nor is Scala despite static typing.

zmmmmm6y ago

slifin6y ago

It relies on the implementation of its runtime, JVM, .net, JavaScript, BeamVM etc but uses it's own language for those operations, slurp/barf etc

So as a developer it's all the same until you start leveraging the features of your particular runtime but this does make code sharing viable

davidw6y ago

There are JVM versions of Python, Ruby and Tcl, so it's not really about the VM itself.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse