undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmschuster916y ago0 comments

> Like a saying, don't bail out corporations so shareholders learn.

I agree with you for self-inflicted problems (such as the financial crisis, or a lack of general funds).

Requiring all corporations to hold enough cash for 6 months of runway with 0 income however? That's an extreme requirement on which most if not all companies would fail.

0 comments

_0w8t6y ago

The current situation implies that not holding cash for 6 months and using loans for day-to-day operations was a premature optimization. Essentially corporations assumed that in the time of prolonged crises they would be bailed out by taxpayers and optimized for an extra profit for shareholders. The profit that was extracted from all taxpayers.

bradleyjg6y ago

That’s not necessarily the case. They’d have to either have that cash on hand or be able to raise it in the debt or equity markets. If these are long term viable businesses, I don’t see why they shouldn’t be able to do just that. Doesn’t seem like any are trying because they’d rather get a government handout.

Fair weather capitalists.

mschuster91OP6y ago

> or be able to raise it in the debt or equity markets

The debt/equity markets are beyond fucked at the moment. Relying on them is what led the financial industry to the 2008 crisis and it certainly won't be a good idea to rely on them in future pandemics.

> Fair weather capitalists.

The entire point of governments in a capitalist system is to deal with stuff that is too big for companies and individual people to handle - which a pandemic certainly is.

bradleyjg6y ago

The markets are liquid, the government is making sure of that. They might not have the pricing that companies think they deserve, but such is life.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsmschuster916y ago0 comments

> Like a saying, don't bail out corporations so shareholders learn.

I agree with you for self-inflicted problems (such as the financial crisis, or a lack of general funds).

Requiring all corporations to hold enough cash for 6 months of runway with 0 income however? That's an extreme requirement on which most if not all companies would fail.

0 comments

_0w8t6y ago

bradleyjg6y ago

Fair weather capitalists.

mschuster91OP6y ago

> or be able to raise it in the debt or equity markets

> Fair weather capitalists.

The entire point of governments in a capitalist system is to deal with stuff that is too big for companies and individual people to handle - which a pandemic certainly is.

bradleyjg6y ago

The markets are liquid, the government is making sure of that. They might not have the pricing that companies think they deserve, but such is life.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse