I don't know about the next edition; `as` is also used for a small number of non-numeric conversions, like turning a reference into a raw pointer or for creating a trait object. In order to completely remove `as`, you would need to first introduce alternatives to those (the trait object use case specifically might be a bit weird as a method rather than a keyword, but I don't know if that's a big problem).

Alternatively one could just deprecate `as` for numeric conversions, although there are still some library holes that would need to be patched up (e.g. other than `as` I don't know of an existing single method to say that you want a fast integer conversion routine that merely truncates a u64 into a u32; right now the alternative is `try_into`, which does a runtime check and returns a Result). It might also exacerbate tensions with some people who for quite a while have been grumpy that Rust requires frequent explicit numeric conversions when doing things like indexing (which always requires a `usize` type, so you see `foo[bar as usize]` unless people want to always work with usizes directly); would these people be happier if that were `foo[bar.as_usize()]` instead, or would this all be blocked on a discussion about being more lenient with numeric conversions?