The cost difference between new and used is truly immense.
A new Cessna 172 starts at around $400,000, and that's before you start checking off things on the options list.
Used can be as low as $20,000 for examples for the 1960s. If you thought depreciation on luxury cars was bad...
The GA system is already frankly dieing due to ever increasing costs. Your suggestion would just kill it for good.