undefined | Better HN

0 pointsido5y ago0 comments

Software just isn't a focus for the German economy, it's more industrial machinery & automotive.

And Germany actually has among the highest amount of immigration in the world so not sure why you think they don't let people in. In my experience it is actually easier to move here than to the US (I'm an immigrant).

The places where it's a problem are those that people leave, like Bulgaria and Romania. There are basically enough "cheap" immigrants available from poorer European countries that the wealthy ones don't need to also additionally increase the rate of immigration from outside Europe.

0 comments

throwaway8943455y ago

I was speaking to Europe in general, but good to know about Germany specifically. I was asking about Europe generally because it seems like I’ve heard of a number of European countries struggling with declining populations in recent years, and if it’s a problem throughout the EU, then perhaps the EU would be better off by loosening its immigration requirements.

idoOP5y ago

It's mostly a problem in countries that aren't doing well economically and thus their young people leave to other (mostly also European) countries.

You cant make immigration easy only in these countries as once you are in the EU you can then move to any other EU state (there is some wait required, like a year I think). So people will basically use these as a jump off point to the countries they actually want to go to (which do not lack immigrants).

I believe the solution is to invest in the poorer countries to make them attractive enough so that their diaspora wishes to return and young people don't want to leave en masse to begin with.

throwaway8943455y ago

Right. That makes sense. If it’s not a pan-EU problem then easing immigration restrictions across the EU won’t help. I wonder if they could be more creative, for example, allowing people to work in those countries with negative population growth but not the wealthier countries (e.g., Germany). Maybe after working in a poorer country for 5-10 years you earn the right to work anywhere in the EU.

But yes, investment in poorer countries also seems reasonable.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsido5y ago0 comments

Software just isn't a focus for the German economy, it's more industrial machinery & automotive.

0 comments

throwaway8943455y ago

idoOP5y ago

It's mostly a problem in countries that aren't doing well economically and thus their young people leave to other (mostly also European) countries.

I believe the solution is to invest in the poorer countries to make them attractive enough so that their diaspora wishes to return and young people don't want to leave en masse to begin with.

throwaway8943455y ago

But yes, investment in poorer countries also seems reasonable.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse