undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdjrobstep5y ago0 comments

You just said that "hand over your watch or get shot" is choice. So then is "hand over your tax or go to prison", yes?

0 comments

I said that libertarians use "voluntary" to refer to a situation that doesn't involve coercion. I did not say that a coerced individual had no choice in the matter. Why would anyone bother to coerce someone who had no choices?

djrobstepOP5y ago

Coercion implies lack of free choice. That's what it is.

A mugging is coercive precisely because the alternative choice (getting shot) is not meaningful.

chordalkeyboard5y ago

> Coercion implies lack of free choice. That's what it is.

"free choice" != "choice"

"choice" != "voluntary"

I mentioned semantics for a reason.

> A mugging is coercive precisely because the alternative choice (getting shot) is not meaningful.

Its not really desirable but neither is it wholly without meaning. Some things are worth dying for. For some people increasing the cost of robbery to murder for their assailant is one of those things.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

chordalkeyboard5y ago

djrobstepOP5y ago

Coercion implies lack of free choice. That's what it is.

A mugging is coercive precisely because the alternative choice (getting shot) is not meaningful.

chordalkeyboard5y ago

> Coercion implies lack of free choice. That's what it is.

"free choice" != "choice"

"choice" != "voluntary"

I mentioned semantics for a reason.

> A mugging is coercive precisely because the alternative choice (getting shot) is not meaningful.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse