undefined | Better HN

0 pointsMacha5y ago0 comments

This is mostly untrue.

There was no requirement to blacklist gab. Mastodon clients on f-droid are allowed let users use Gab.

What f-droid does not allow is apps preconfigured to connect to Gab, or who's primary purpose is to connect to Gab.

There was even a petition to have fdroid remove an app (fedilab) that had a blacklist to disallow Gab then removed it, claiming that removing Gab from the blacklist was specifically endorsing it, and there were some people who tried to claiming that not apps that were not blacklisting Gab when other apps did meant those apps primary purpose was to connect to Gab, but f-droid weren't having it: https://gitlab.com/fdroid/fdroiddata/-/issues/1736.

However, they did consider an app that was a straight fork tracking another with the only change being the removal of a blacklist to be disallowed.

0 comments

dleslie5y ago

So.. They don't ban apps that connect to verboten services, but they do ban apps that acknowledge the existence of verboten services, and apps that remove barriers to verboten services.

That's cutting the hair mightily fine.

Kinrany5y ago

Could you rephrase the fourth paragraph?

MachaOP5y ago

fedilab was allowed despite removing a blacklist. This was because not having a blacklist was not the app's sole distinction from other mastodon apps (it had a majorly different UI), so its purpose was determined to be more than just accessing Gab.

However, some fdroid users asked for its removal. They felt removing the blacklist feature, which had previously only blocked gab, was itself an endorsement of Gab and indicated the app's purpose was to access Gab since the other available mastodon app (Tusky) still had a blacklist.

fdroid did not agree and fedilab is still available.

OpenTusky was not allowed as it was literally Tusky with the server blacklist removed, created in response to Tusky blocking Gab. It also advertised this in the app description, so fdroid judged it to be primarily for accessing gab and removed it.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse