Curator idea is a cool one -- would def get me to visit, but prob not subscribe. I second gabaix´s comment about refining the core value prop a bit more.
For example: As an Alabama fan, I subscribe to TiderInsider because there´s a perception that the guys that post on that forum are really "in the know" -- so I pay to get access to that early intel, tips, credible (and not-so-credible) rumors, etc. from insiders with the program. Site doesnt look like much, but you can get info there days/weeks before it hits mainstream outlets like ESPN/SI.