undefined | Better HN

0 pointsintended14y ago0 comments

I would love it to catch on, but there are massive social/legal/moral issues with it.

Eg 1- someone going through a depressive phase hits up with a troll (ref: case where someone was in a chat room, streaming a video of himself just before he committed suicide, people in the chat room egged him on)

Eg 2- Someone is suffering a depressive/manic episode, but turns to this and is not directed to medical help immediately OR someone has an issue which would require them to go to a professional, but the listener is not trained/aware and hence can't give them critical advice

Eg 3- Young adult who has had a traumatic day turns to this service, gets put in touch with someone who has strong beliefs. (or even mild ones)

Eg 4- High Karma person is taping calls of people talking to them

0 comments

joeyespo14y ago

Yes, I do agree that there will be some edge cases with moral and legal issues. For everyone else with something on their minds, most of the time you just need to talk it out with another human being. It's the emotional side of their problems that they need help with. They shouldn't really be looking for advice here.

Kind of like AirBnB (for example) needing to have both parties be trustworthy, this will also require an element of trust. In the sense of confidentiality and compassion.

Just because the problems aren't immediately solvable doesn't mean we should avoid it though. We should instead try different things. Maybe on different sites or throughout the evolution of this one. But ultimately test to see what keeps the abusers away and also avoids the social/legal/moral issues.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse