undefined | Better HN

0 pointsGekkePrutser4y ago0 comments

I don't think the backyard idiot would have this in their backyard: https://amsat-dl.org/en/20-meter-antenna/ which is what they used to receive this. Sending control commands would be even harder. Mars is far. But for earth orbiting says this is more of a risk indeed.

The uplink (control commands)would be encrypted for sure but the downlink (telemetry) is often not for scientific missions. For military or commercial it's a different thing obviously.

Even SpaceX' launch cams (downlink) were not encrypted for a while and amateurs received them. Only when this made the news they started encrypting them. Probably because they do military launches too (the cameras for those on their web feed shut down when the payload is visible, but this would possibly show those)

https://www.rtl-sdr.com/receiving-video-directly-from-a-spac...

0 comments

GravitasFailure4y ago

Apparently the encryption has to do with needing to have a license from NOAA in order to broadcast images of Earth.

https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/5/17197742/spacex-falcon-9-r...

GekkePrutserOP4y ago

Interesting. It makes no sense at all in this case because the stated reason for the law (capturing troop movements) is impossible here. The resolution and focal length is way too low to see anything smaller than a few miles in diameter :)

But it is a law... It should be repealed or specified in more detail IMO (e.g. only applying to really high detail levels). But I can imagine the US Govt has bigger fish to fry right now with a raging pandemic.

tastyfreeze4y ago

Thank you for sharing.

NOAA requiring a license for images of Earth is infuriating. Do they require other countries to get a license as well?

GravitasFailure4y ago

My understanding is it's intertwined with national security issues. NOAA doesn't have the ability to demand a license from other nations, though there may be some treaty obligations they adhere to.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsGekkePrutser4y ago0 comments

The uplink (control commands)would be encrypted for sure but the downlink (telemetry) is often not for scientific missions. For military or commercial it's a different thing obviously.

https://www.rtl-sdr.com/receiving-video-directly-from-a-spac...

0 comments

GravitasFailure4y ago

Apparently the encryption has to do with needing to have a license from NOAA in order to broadcast images of Earth.

https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/5/17197742/spacex-falcon-9-r...

GekkePrutserOP4y ago

tastyfreeze4y ago

Thank you for sharing.

NOAA requiring a license for images of Earth is infuriating. Do they require other countries to get a license as well?

GravitasFailure4y ago

My understanding is it's intertwined with national security issues. NOAA doesn't have the ability to demand a license from other nations, though there may be some treaty obligations they adhere to.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse