Ask HN: Why do Greek or Russian characters get URL encoded?

1 pointsgreeklish4y ago3 comments

Why don't browsers URL encode just the special characters such as ?, & and whitespaces when a URL is copied?

The resulting URLs would be much cleaner and easier to understand for native speakers.

3 comments

I think technically a URL/URI is only supposed to contain ASCII characters, and certain things that expect URL input will want ASCII only. However, all modern browsers can convert from Unicode to punycode (in the domain name) and percent-encoding (in the path). So I don't really understand why browsers only let you copy the percent-encoded form easily.

WizardOfLight4y ago

It’s to avoid malware domains and similar applications of various malfeasance. In short, because they can be used to obfuscate the actually intended url copied, such as fасеbook <— this has Cyrillic characters in it you can’t otherwise notice.

ignoranceprior4y ago

Try going to e.g. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%A7%CF%81%CE%BF%CE%BD%CE%BF...

When visiting the page (at least on Firefox), the location bar displays the intended characters, but when copying it you get the percent-encoded form. If the reason for percent-encoding was just to make scams more obvious, shouldn't the form shown in the browser interface also be URL-encoded?

By the way, it seems like that is a much stronger argument when applied to domian names than when applied to the part of the URL after the slash.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

Ask HN: Why do Greek or Russian characters get URL encoded?

1 pointsgreeklish4y ago3 comments

Why don't browsers URL encode just the special characters such as ?, & and whitespaces when a URL is copied?

The resulting URLs would be much cleaner and easier to understand for native speakers.

3 comments

ignoranceprior4y ago

WizardOfLight4y ago

ignoranceprior4y ago

Try going to e.g. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%A7%CF%81%CE%BF%CE%BD%CE%BF...

By the way, it seems like that is a much stronger argument when applied to domian names than when applied to the part of the URL after the slash.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse