undefined | Better HN

0 pointsanonymoushn4y ago0 comments

Dominion and Homeworlds are pretty complicated! Maybe you can start with a simpler game like Splendor.

In my 2-player Splendor rules engine, the following actions are possible:

1. Purchase a holding. (90 possible actions, one for each holding)

2. If you do not have 3 reserved cards, reserve a card and take a gold chip if possible. (93 possible actions, one for each holding and one for each deck of facedown cards)

3. If there are 4 chips of the same color in a pile, take 2 chips of that color. (5 possible actions)

4. Take 3 chips of different colors, or 2 chips of different colors if only 2 are available, or 1 chip if only 1 is available. (25 possible actions)

5. If after any action you have at least 11 chips, return 1 chip. (6 possible actions which are never legal at the same time as any other actions)

This still doesn't correctly implement the rules though. In the actual game, you'd be allowed to spend gold chips when you don't need to, which would make purchasing holdings contain extra decisions after you pick which holding to purchase about which chips you'd like to keep.

0 comments

fho4y ago

I actually played Splendor for the first (three) time(s) some time ago and honestly didn't really like it. It's a very simple game, true. I feel like there are not many decision points for me as a player and therefore there is not much strategy involved. But maybe that is just my view after very few games.

(At the same time that probably makes it a good choice for a game implementation)

Thing is that for all my examples above I had a "good" reason to implement that specific game:

1. Dominion (shortly after it came out) To evaluate strategies to best my friends (obviously). 2. Eclipse Has a nice rock-paper-scissors type of ship combat, where you can counter every enemy build (if you have enough time and resources). Calculating the odds of winning would be interesting. 3. Homeworlds Seems to be a very fascinating game. But without any players to compete with [0] ... AI to the rescue ;-)

[0] I am aware of SDG where I could play online, but that site is in decay mode. Getting an account involved mailing the maintainer and those times I tried to start a game no players showed up.

henshao4y ago

I think splendor gets more interesting if your opponents are also trying to be strategic. You can see what color chips they are picking up, which lets you know what they are aiming for, which influences what card you want to aim for or reserve. Mid game, you can see what colors other people are missing and try to corner colors to give you room to breath and pick up cards. You can also see the set of colors people are holding to see which of the 4 final bonus point cards are being fought over.

I like the game for what it is. I'd say, surprisingly strategic.

piyh4y ago

It's like if you turned tuning magic mana bases into a stand alone game.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse