undefined | Better HN

0 pointsr2834924y ago0 comments

The malicious/abusive parts of nonfree software are almost always tied to it's updatability. Avoiding updatable nonfree software prevents users from entering into an abusive relationship with a nonfree software vendor. https://www.gnu.org/proprietary/proprietary.en.html, 550 instances of malicious functionalities, I'd bet all instances are for software where the vendor can update it.

Your argument is like "Banning guns will incentivize people to use knives, people who want to only ban guns for violence sake are hypocrites." There is a kernel of truth, but it's really just ignoring the bigger reality.

0 comments

marcan_424y ago

People keep bringing this up like proprietary software can always be unilaterally updated by the vendor. That's not how it works with firmware blobs, the vast, vast majority of the time. The user has the choice to run whatever firmware version they want, for as long as they want. They have strictly more freedom than if the software were not updatable, since they can choose the least evil version.

I can't believe people are still trying to use this argument. It's plainly evident that mutable software gives you more choice than immutable software. Making the argument that autoupdaters are evil and can be abused doesn't suddenly make all mutable software more evil than immutable software.

marcan_424y ago

Incidentally, I'm on their list as a victim:

> 2010-03

> Sony restricted access to the PlayStation 3 GPU, so people who installed a GNU/Linux operating system on the console couldn't use it at full capacity. When some of them broke the restriction, Sony removed the ability to install other operating systems. Then users broke that restriction too, but got sued by Sony.

I'm one of the people who got sued by Sony. And I still think the FSF's take on all this is terrible.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsr2834924y ago0 comments

0 comments

marcan_424y ago

Incidentally, I'm on their list as a victim:

> 2010-03

I'm one of the people who got sued by Sony. And I still think the FSF's take on all this is terrible.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse