undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbooi3y ago0 comments

Would you recommend RedwoodJS for green field projects? How would you say an opinionated framework like this works in the medium to late maturity? Is it easy or even possible to switch out components with more "enterprisy" solutions?

0 comments

canyonero3y ago

> Would you recommend RedwoodJS for green field projects?

IMO if you want to run PostgreSQL, React and GraphQL with the least amount of friction and decision making, RedwoodJS is great choice.

> How would you say an opinionated framework like this works in the medium to late maturity?

If you run a frontend-heavy and/or TS/JS shop and don't mind the tradeoffs of something like Ruby on Rails, then I see no limitations to building whatever you want with it.

> Is it easy or even possible to switch out components with more "enterprisy" solutions?

Not sure what that would look like, so I can't comment.

tootie3y ago

Being able to more quickly bootstrap a project is about 0.01% of the value of a platform. If that's the pitch then I'm not buying. I'll choose the platform that's easiest to debug, maintain and expand.

mojombo3y ago

RedwoodJS has been about long term maintainability from the very beginning. This is part of why we chose GraphQL as a core component. It's more complex at first, but in the long run it gives you multi-client capabilities without rewriting your backend, and provides excellent separation of concerns. We still try to make Redwood as easy to get started with as possible, but in the tradeoff between "quick bootstrapping" and "long term maintainability", we tend to choose the latter.

fishtoaster3y ago

That's definitely a valid view, but I'd say it's not the only one.

For some usecases, quick bootsrapping is incredibly valuable - eg an early-stage startup.

That was the historical case for Rails: quick to get started and not too bad to maintain/expand as you grow (it got better about later stages in the later years as the ecosystem matured). That's a tradeoff that can make a ton of sense when you're starting a project that has a good chance of not existing in 6 months and where every day of initial productivity is incredibly valuable.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse