I had 30 second downtime last week. First time.
I like that they offer, ok priced, dedicated machines (though I'm on their "bare-metal" machines for now).
The only problem is that they don't innovate. They are where AWS was back when it started. Shared storage...dns...virtual ips..load balancers...queues...(and the list goes on), doesn't exist.
If I wasn't such a cheap ass, I'd use Amazon.
In terms of the hosting providers I've worked with in a professional capacity, they've all had their ups and downs.
I couldn't really recommend one over the other, but a lot of people seem keen on Rackspace, and I don't think anyone has ever told me that they enjoyed dealing with 1and1.
(Owning a hosting company has a few perks, finally!)
As for innovators are concerned, Linode is doing good stuff. Can't think of anyone else in the space doing anything remotely interesting quite frankly.
Edit: I just saw it [1]... Is your qualm performance-based, or ethical?
Will you design my web site for me?
No, we will not. Our design skills are horrifyingly bad anyway. We like to stick to what we're good at, which is hosting sites, not creating them. Our current public site reflects this.
Hostgator's 10/mth plan and cpanel is plenty easy for me to put all my simple forums and blogs on.
I set up my university design department with Dreamhost because it's easy for the layman and you can add multiple accounts with different lvls of access. If you need that...
I hear MT is good like AWS if you are like to configure everything on your own.
Several clients I did work for had GoDaddy hosting and I would run into all sorts of issues with them.