undefined | Better HN

0 pointsChuckNorris893y ago0 comments

>I think people vastly underestimate the importance of infantry support

Do you now what's funny? Even RTS videogames like the Command and Conquer series or Star-Craft made this point clear early in our childhoods.

Tanks will be eaten alive by hoards of cheap disposable units, so you always had to support them with anti-infantry units if you wanted them to be useful in battle.

0 comments

UncleMeat3y ago

In the modern day, humans are not necessarily "cheap disposable units." At least for the US, it is not politically feasible to have 50,000-100,000 people die in a war anymore. 4,431 US soldiers were killed in Iraq. The calculus has changed and now dollars are cheaper than lives.

ChuckNorris89OP3y ago

>humans are not necessarily "cheap disposable units"

Putin and most of the Russian military doctrine would beg to differ.

UncleMeat3y ago

"Not necessarily."

It depends on the nation and their political situation.

AnimalMuppet3y ago

To what degree do you think that Russia's losses in Afghanistan led to the fall of the Soviet Union?

Since 1945, Russia hasn't shown that it can accept a war of mass casualties without political fallout. Russian military doctrine may say that it can, but Putin would be unwise to assume so.

bena3y ago

Yeah, you don't make units, you make battalions.

Siege tanks are grouped with marines and firebats for protection, Marines and medics run with medics for assistance. Have your infantry out front. Move to a location, plant your troops, put your tanks in siege mode, rain hellfire down upon aerial defenses and approaching units so your Battlecruisers can come in with their Vulture and Wraith support to decimate a base.

It takes a village. You know, to destroy the other guys village. But still. Villages.

metadat3y ago

Yes, the Warcraft II and III tank units get scrapped real quick if you don't protect them!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsChuckNorris893y ago0 comments

>I think people vastly underestimate the importance of infantry support

Do you now what's funny? Even RTS videogames like the Command and Conquer series or Star-Craft made this point clear early in our childhoods.

Tanks will be eaten alive by hoards of cheap disposable units, so you always had to support them with anti-infantry units if you wanted them to be useful in battle.

0 comments

UncleMeat3y ago

ChuckNorris89OP3y ago

>humans are not necessarily "cheap disposable units"

Putin and most of the Russian military doctrine would beg to differ.

UncleMeat3y ago

"Not necessarily."

It depends on the nation and their political situation.

AnimalMuppet3y ago

To what degree do you think that Russia's losses in Afghanistan led to the fall of the Soviet Union?

Since 1945, Russia hasn't shown that it can accept a war of mass casualties without political fallout. Russian military doctrine may say that it can, but Putin would be unwise to assume so.

bena3y ago

Yeah, you don't make units, you make battalions.

It takes a village. You know, to destroy the other guys village. But still. Villages.

metadat3y ago

Yes, the Warcraft II and III tank units get scrapped real quick if you don't protect them!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse