Ask HN: Any tools to search video based on audio?

27 pointsmuxneo3y ago12 comments

Hello,

I am wondering if there is any tool (good to have opensource) which lets you search an audio+video file based on the audio. Basically enter a search string containing text and the result is the video player showing the video frame containing the audio in which this text exist

12 comments

PainfullyNormal3y ago

Have you seen this post on videogrep? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31483548

0des3y ago

Thank you for sharing videogrep, I'm adding it to my toolbox.

Suddenly I'm able to see and reply to this comment - so despite Dang telling me that telling you this isn't allowed, you might want to check what's up with your account. Just about everything you say is greyed out as soon as you say it, despite everything I saw in your history being normal, and it seems to go back a while. Just letting you know before you waste more time on otherwise insightful comments that get seen by only those of us who elect to seeing it.

PainfullyNormal3y ago

Thanks for letting me know! I reached out to Dang. He said I got trapped in a spam filter and he fixed it.

If you're listening, Dang, thanks for responding and handling everything so quickly!

muxneoOP3y ago

Where is the like button :)

kingkool683y ago

There's https://filmot.com/ which searches/indexes on YouTube captions and will take you right to the point in the video that matches your search.

muxneoOP3y ago

thanks. I am looking for my own videos and particulary not youtube. The idea is to host my own videos on my site to be able to search them. Therefore looking for an opensource solution

codingdave3y ago

If it is just for your own videos, you don't need a video search solution - you need a transcription process or service. Then you would have timestamped words/phrases, which you could put into a database and just query/search that DB.

0des3y ago

If I didn't have showdead, I'd have no idea about videogrep or PainfullyNormal's comment (which I cannot vouch for to comment in thanks, or upvote, its just [dead])

Admins - Get rid of whatever behavior gets random people on blocklists, or at least make it finite in duration. I was told by Dan to stop mentioning this when I see it (which is unethical in my opinion), but its just sad how often it happens now. Even an asshole is right sometimes (not saying this guys an asshole).

mrkramer3y ago

I had an idea to create commercial service for this; but I'm afraid it would cost me too much to transcribe videos. Short videos are not costly to transcribe but hours long videos are. At the end of the day I might do it because Moore's law is our friend and it should get cheaper and cheaper over the years.

bryanrasmussen3y ago

asr (automatic speech recognition) https://github.com/topics/asr-model

The_Amp_Walrus3y ago

Descript maybe

0des3y ago

didn't echonest used to do this?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

12 comments

PainfullyNormal3y ago

Have you seen this post on videogrep? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31483548

0des3y ago

Thank you for sharing videogrep, I'm adding it to my toolbox.

PainfullyNormal3y ago

Thanks for letting me know! I reached out to Dang. He said I got trapped in a spam filter and he fixed it.

If you're listening, Dang, thanks for responding and handling everything so quickly!

muxneoOP3y ago

Where is the like button :)

kingkool683y ago

There's https://filmot.com/ which searches/indexes on YouTube captions and will take you right to the point in the video that matches your search.

muxneoOP3y ago

thanks. I am looking for my own videos and particulary not youtube. The idea is to host my own videos on my site to be able to search them. Therefore looking for an opensource solution

codingdave3y ago

0des3y ago

If I didn't have showdead, I'd have no idea about videogrep or PainfullyNormal's comment (which I cannot vouch for to comment in thanks, or upvote, its just [dead])

mrkramer3y ago

bryanrasmussen3y ago

asr (automatic speech recognition) https://github.com/topics/asr-model

The_Amp_Walrus3y ago

Descript maybe

0des3y ago

didn't echonest used to do this?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse