undefined | Better HN

0 pointsraxxorraxor3y ago0 comments

I doubt this is the issue although there might be cultural differences. In my country women never picked up CS in significant numbers.

Also I don't understand how someone is blamed if they have no interest and you turn around and blame it on men that allegedly discriminate. It is very unlikely that discrimination is the issue if there wasn't to many female computer scientists in the first place. On the contrary, scare stories about "tech bros" probably scare away more people overall. Women and men for that matter.

The book is about Silicon Valley that draws in all kinds of crowds but the usual developer is mostly introverted and polite. It is not all stereotypes but there is a difference between most programmers and most salesmen.

I reject the analysis that there are systemic issues, there is no evidence at all. This has become a religion of some sort.

0 comments

guiambros3y ago

> ... if they have no interest and you turn around and blame it on men that allegedly discriminate

The very first programmer was a woman, and in the early days of computing history they were over 40% of all programmers [1]. The idea that "they have no interest" is bullshit [2]; talk to women in tech (and the ones who quit) and you'll quickly learn why that is the case.

> I reject the analysis that there are systemic issues, there is no evidence at all.

That's the same argument used by folks who deny systemic racism in the US, despite decades of historical context [3]. It's a convenient position, particularly for those in a place of privilege. Of course you're free to believe in whatever you want, but if you don't want to put in the effort and learn from other's perspectives, then you're part of the problem.

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2014/10/06/34...

[2] https://www.amazon.com/Brotopia-Emily-Chang-audiobook/dp/B07...

[3] https://www.amazon.com/Caste-Origins-Discontents-Isabel-Wilk...

raxxorraxorOP3y ago

I talked to all 5 women in tech that started to study with me. 1 got her degree together with 20 men from over 120 students, the other all changed subjects after the first semesters. How can there be discrimination if there wasn't even a possibility for it? This was technical computer science that is even worse than general computer science in regards to gender ratio. It just makes no sense at all, it defies any logic to propose this can be discrimination. There might be some cases, but there needs to be an effect that is far more relevant. The numbers of people starting computer science is evidence you cannot just reject, you leave reality behind at that point.

I lived with women in a shared apartment who studied economics. They simply didn't like computer science.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse