undefined | Better HN

0 pointsfauigerzigerk3y ago0 comments

>Culture has a HUGE impact on psychology.

I would agree with that in general, but hunger seems like such an incredibly old issue to deal with from evolutionary perspective. Managing hunger is something "we" have been doing for millions of years and it has always been at the very center of our survival as a species.

The idea that a cultural group could lose its ability to deal with such a key psychological and biological necessity in a short period of time just seems far less likely to me than a change in habits brought about by far more recent industrial and socioeconomic circumstances.

Take that from yet another pseudonymous internet autodidact ;-)

0 comments

csours3y ago

> The idea that a cultural group could lose its ability to deal with such a key psychological and biological necessity in a short period of time just seems far less likely to me than a change in habits brought about by industrial and socio-economic circumstances.

But those industrial and socio-economic circumstances also had a huge impact on culture! It's super complicated!

I am not strongly anti-capitalist, but consider the impact of capitalism on food:

Take low cost ingredients. Put them together in an appealing way. Sell the product at a relatively low price (higher than the ingredients, but not much). Advertise the product widely in such a way to condition people to desire your product.

I am describing junk food of course. Walk into a convenience store or look at the checkout lines of a grocery store. Look at all the food you are conditioned to desire.

edit: I am not blaming capitalism as the single cause of obesity. There is much more to it than that.

fauigerzigerkOP3y ago

Well, exactly, but would you really describe these cultural changes as a disease of managing hunger on an individual psychological level (which is how I understood the term)?

If something like what you're describing is going on then our psychological ability to manage hunger hasn't changed at all. Other things have changed, which is my whole point.

csours3y ago

Yes, the conditions we live under have changed; the big question is "Why are some individuals so much more affected by the new environmental effects than others and what should we do about it"

When we gain weight, we understand we need to eat less to lose weight. But that obviously does not work for many many people.

I'm carrying excess fat right now. Abolishing capitalism or taxing soda (or whatever other social, political, or cultural changes you would make) won't get rid of that fat. It is commendable to work on the social causes of obesity. I frame it as an individual psychological issue because it is an individual experience. If it was a matter of finding "the right foods to eat and avoid" or any particular set of facts that could convey how to actually lose weight, then the problem would be solved.

In other words, you can't tell someone to be hungry. Or at least, that doesn't sell any books or diet plans.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

csours3y ago

But those industrial and socio-economic circumstances also had a huge impact on culture! It's super complicated!

I am not strongly anti-capitalist, but consider the impact of capitalism on food:

I am describing junk food of course. Walk into a convenience store or look at the checkout lines of a grocery store. Look at all the food you are conditioned to desire.

edit: I am not blaming capitalism as the single cause of obesity. There is much more to it than that.

fauigerzigerkOP3y ago

Well, exactly, but would you really describe these cultural changes as a disease of managing hunger on an individual psychological level (which is how I understood the term)?

If something like what you're describing is going on then our psychological ability to manage hunger hasn't changed at all. Other things have changed, which is my whole point.

csours3y ago

Yes, the conditions we live under have changed; the big question is "Why are some individuals so much more affected by the new environmental effects than others and what should we do about it"

When we gain weight, we understand we need to eat less to lose weight. But that obviously does not work for many many people.

In other words, you can't tell someone to be hungry. Or at least, that doesn't sell any books or diet plans.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse