Show HN: The Poetry Corner – A React Native app to read public domain poems (opens in new tab)

What a great idea. What I like about poetry is it makes the idea of people in general more plausibly likable by reminding us that a strangers inner life is possible. If we were only as deep as our tweets and the other things we do for reflected approval there would be really nothing to save. It seems urgent to find a way to see people as more than the symbols we have come to represent.

Funny how media means we are all relating to one another as symbols, and then we're surprised when we treat each other like them.

App downloaded. In the Collections list, a category for "Wise" would be a big draw, as poetry is a dense vehicle for education. (thinking Blake's proverbs of hell, Auden's one liners, Holzer's truisms, etc.)

This is a great idea and it looks super clean. One thing I noticed is the spacing and line breaks are not always rendered the way the author intended. For example in Percy Shelley's Ozymandias compare the text in the app to the Poetry.orgs text https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46565/ozymandias

I like that you're focused on curation rather than "algorithmic" feeding of content. The Criterion Collection does this with movies. One thing they do is have guest curators make lists of their favorite movies. My suggestion would be to have authors create guest curations of their favorite poems. Just an idea.

Just downloaded it. As someone who used to read more poetry and has fallen off, I like the idea! Maybe this will prod me back into the habit.

One bug report: I can’t select text in the poem. Wanted to look up a word and can’t figure out any way. Was that disabled intentionally?

Looks nice, congrats on the launch. Two things that aren’t clear to me from the App Store page (I haven’t downloaded the app):

1. Why is account creation necessary? Why can’t I just store/sync my bookmarked poems with iCloud?

2. What the subscription is or does. The most recent change notes say that a Pro plan with ‘additional features’ was added but doesn’t elaborate beyond that.

For anyone in Germany, if you need to recite a poem, I have a poem you can remember from my book (printed! :-)

   Au
   Au
   Au

Clean UI. Nice work. Do you hand curate each poem?

Beautiful! Any plans for web or Android native?

This is a beautiful looking app, but I can't help thinking it exemplifies everything that is wrong with modern web development.

Firstly, why is this a native app and not a website? Oh actually, it is a website: https://thepoetrycorner.app , except some parts of it (search?, accounts?) don't seem to be working in the browser.

Lets see what the pages are like. Here's one: https://thepoetrycorner.app/robert-lee-frost/the-road-not-ta...

The poem itself is 769 characters of plain text, including the title, attribution, and line breaks. 769 bytes.

The webpage is 810 kilobytes, in 25 files.

The app is 39.3 megabytes.

The App store page says there are "more than 30,000 poems to explore". I bet you could fit all 30,000 in less than 39.3 MB if you tried.

Looking in web inspector I see lots of JSON files loaded on every click. I wonder if it works with JS disabled. It does? Page weight drops to 56.6 KB, which is quite reasonable. So why did all that JSON need to be loaded?

This could have been a really clean and lightweight website. The content is plain text with an occasional image. It's perfect for plain HTML. Instead it's a 40 MB native app. The road not taken, indeed.