undefined | Better HN

0 pointsRL_Quine3y ago0 comments

Nonsense. The 10th gen X1 Carbon has basically nothing functional unless you are running master kernel, and even then it's not completely there. It's just an unusable paperweight at the moment, the OLED screen is pretty though.

0 comments

dm3193y ago

As a long-time Thinkpad user, it usually helps to not go for the latest/greatest, but even so, the time between release and 99% working linux is in the region of months with Thinkpads, whereas it can be years-never with Mac.

I had some issues with my AMD X13 when getting it new - but they weren't show-stopping, just annoying, and they got ironed out over the next 6 months.

rayiner3y ago

But that supports the point OP made above. Each generation of Lenovo laptop changes out lots of parts (presumably based on changing prices and supply contracts). Apple laptop hardware tends to be stable over time.

viraptor3y ago

> Apple laptop hardware tends to be stable over time.

I'm confused where you got that idea. T2 chips changed a lot. The most recent Intel MBPs have a different wifi with a known-broken firmware for Linux. The sound handling has also changed and hasn't been reverse engineered yet since 2019. And that's before we even get to changing the entire architecture to M1. How is that less changes than lenovo?

nicoburns3y ago

> whereas it can be years-never with Mac

Notably the Asahi project got M2 laptops up to parity with the M1 family in ~48 hours of dev work. No doubt this won't always be the case (there's bound to be major hardware revisions at some point) but at the moment this is quite promising looking towards the future.

dm3193y ago

Yes, I think the difference this time is motivation (because M1!) and some money going this way.

petepete3y ago

I have a 7th gen X1 Carbon and everything, including the fingerprint reader, worked out of the box with Fedora.

RL_QuineOP3y ago

It is from August 2019 though.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

dm3193y ago

I had some issues with my AMD X13 when getting it new - but they weren't show-stopping, just annoying, and they got ironed out over the next 6 months.

rayiner3y ago

viraptor3y ago

> Apple laptop hardware tends to be stable over time.

nicoburns3y ago

> whereas it can be years-never with Mac

dm3193y ago

Yes, I think the difference this time is motivation (because M1!) and some money going this way.

petepete3y ago

I have a 7th gen X1 Carbon and everything, including the fingerprint reader, worked out of the box with Fedora.

RL_QuineOP3y ago

It is from August 2019 though.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse