undefined | Better HN

0 pointskjerkegor3y ago0 comments

> If he did cheat it should be really obvious because his performance will suddenly drop

I mean, Magnus is so much more better player than Hans that even if Hans didn't cheat he would probably be worse in rematch. But in all sports sometimes underdogs win. In couple yt videos i watched it was said that Magnus played bad game and that Hans already gained an advantage in opening. Hans said that he prepared opening play but if he is indeed a cheater he maybe used engine just for opening. We'll probably never get an answer if there was cheating or not

0 comments

armchairhacker3y ago

Maybe he will get away with it if he only cheated against Magnus, and only in that one match. Because it's perfectly reasonable for him to play against Magnus many more times and lost.

But if he cheated a lot more (as Magnus seems to allege) then he'll also lose to others he used to beat easily.

EDIT: I think a big issue with chess is this "perfection" mentality. Magnus cannot make a single mistake or lose a single game without it being a big show. Hans beating Magnus this one time, even though he was playing against black, should basically mean nothing - Magnus can probably beat Hans 10 times over. If Hans was beating Magnus 10 times it would be different - but also if he was on a streak to Magnus 10 times he would be playing with a lot more scrutiny.

roflyear3y ago

The guy has beating top-50 players in short time controls. In all kinds of settings (casual, tournaments, online). You don't do that if you're not a strong player.

roflyear3y ago

Of course he used an engine for the opening. Before the game, 100% certain he did.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointskjerkegor3y ago0 comments

> If he did cheat it should be really obvious because his performance will suddenly drop

0 comments

armchairhacker3y ago

Maybe he will get away with it if he only cheated against Magnus, and only in that one match. Because it's perfectly reasonable for him to play against Magnus many more times and lost.

But if he cheated a lot more (as Magnus seems to allege) then he'll also lose to others he used to beat easily.

roflyear3y ago

The guy has beating top-50 players in short time controls. In all kinds of settings (casual, tournaments, online). You don't do that if you're not a strong player.

roflyear3y ago

Of course he used an engine for the opening. Before the game, 100% certain he did.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse