Ask HN: How do you deal with persistent spam from a specific tech company?

2 pointsnish15003y ago6 comments

Magicbricks is a large real-estate portal based out of India. I created my account earlier this year and received a ton of marketing emails. I unsubscribed but continued to received emails.

Next, I proceeded to delete my account. The emails didn't stop.

I raised concern on Twitter. Their support staff assured me the emails would stop. They didn't.

I keep marking their emails as SPAM in Gmail but Gmail doesn't seem to learn the behaviour.

I could create a filter and automatically send their emails to spam but that feels like a personal defeat.

HN: What would you do?

6 comments

gregjor3y ago

Create the filter, move on with my life. Easy to filter if the emails always come from the same domain. Do you really need to feel anything (like defeat) about this?

beardyw3y ago

> I could create a filter and automatically send their emails to spam but that feels like a personal defeat.

What? Use technology to do what it is designed to do.

pwg3y ago

> What would you do?

IP block on their SMTP sender endpoint. But then I host my own email myself, so I can do such things with ease.

gregjor3y ago

In this decade that won’t even work except against people who also host their own email. Most companies use email providers such as Google, Sendgrid, Mailgun, or send out through CRM platforms. Those services have many IP addresses and rotate them to avoid blacklisting. I haven’t seen a company of any size hosting their own outgoing email for at least ten years.

LinuxBender3y ago

In some of the examples you provided they the email campaign providers will create a unique SNAT with a unique FCrDNS for the customer if they are big enough so they don't get in the polluted SNAT pool of smaller companies. In those cases they can still be blocked by regex or sub-domain name.

For the generic SNAT pools of the smaller customers one can at least rate limit those providers and also tag them as Possible Spam or adjust their spam score in tools like Spam-Assassin. It's not perfect but tagging and rate-limiting can help.

AnimalMuppet3y ago

Yeah... that's a bit harder to do with a gmail account...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

Ask HN: How do you deal with persistent spam from a specific tech company?

2 pointsnish15003y ago6 comments

Magicbricks is a large real-estate portal based out of India. I created my account earlier this year and received a ton of marketing emails. I unsubscribed but continued to received emails.

Next, I proceeded to delete my account. The emails didn't stop.

I raised concern on Twitter. Their support staff assured me the emails would stop. They didn't.

I keep marking their emails as SPAM in Gmail but Gmail doesn't seem to learn the behaviour.

I could create a filter and automatically send their emails to spam but that feels like a personal defeat.

HN: What would you do?

6 comments

gregjor3y ago

Create the filter, move on with my life. Easy to filter if the emails always come from the same domain. Do you really need to feel anything (like defeat) about this?

beardyw3y ago

> I could create a filter and automatically send their emails to spam but that feels like a personal defeat.

What? Use technology to do what it is designed to do.

pwg3y ago

> What would you do?

IP block on their SMTP sender endpoint. But then I host my own email myself, so I can do such things with ease.

gregjor3y ago

LinuxBender3y ago

AnimalMuppet3y ago

Yeah... that's a bit harder to do with a gmail account...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse