undefined | Better HN

0 pointssimondotau3y ago0 comments

The emerald mine claim comes from statements made by Errol Musk (Elon's father) who described it as a part share in an Zambian mine which resulted in a total lifetime revenues in the order of a few hundred thousand dollars. None of what Errol has said has been corroborated by anyone. No independent sources exist. It's also worth noting that Zambia is not a conflict gem country and an emerald mine in Zambia would not be morally problematic absent any specific evidence.

(And regardless of any of the above, I've never been particularly enamoured of criticism of a person because of who their parents are or what their parents did. Blaming Elon for being the son of white people in South Africa is kinda gross, actually.)

0 comments

panick21_3y ago

I saw a recent Twitter take that was like:

"Who payed for those computers in the 90s that Musk had access to?"

Its like yeah ok, he wasn't found in a dumbster during a civil war. Is that the level now, where nobody can get any credit because they were not born into abject poverty?

That just basically means that 99% of people who achieve anything don't deserve credit for anything.

Its basically materialist logic taken to an absurd degree.

simondotauOP3y ago

Or those takes where it’s argued that because his companies have many hundreds of employees, it’s literally impossible for Elon to have contributed anything of value whatsoever.

Or even more hilariously, that Elon is some kind of marketing genius. Seriously, the guy is the opposite of a smooth communicator, and leans heavily into his autistic sense of humour. Yet apparently the only reason anyone ever bought a Tesla is because they were suckered in by a slick sales pitch.

_djo_3y ago

Agreed. Though it does seem that Elon's family were quite well socially connected and that at least some of his early success in raising funds comes from that.

For instance, his connection to Roelof Botha, who in turn leveraged the connections made by his father when he was spending a lot of time in the US as South Africa's last apartheid-era foreign minister.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse