undefined | Better HN

0 pointsEFreethought3y ago0 comments

I thought everybody learned that JIT is bad after 9/11.

It seems like the More Bad Advice crowd wants to keep living in a fantasy world.

0 comments

The management consultant comes in, removes slack (increases fragility) and leaves with their fee before shtf.

Interesting; I had not heard that. What specifically about 9/11 do you allege led to the perception that JIT is bad? Looking back, I don't see an obvious connection to either logistics or manufacturing, but I am definitely curious.

EFreethoughtOP3y ago

It was a while back, but I do remember airlines shut down. I think cargo flights got cancelled.

It was not as bad as the COVID lockdowns, but at the time the changes were pretty drastic.

A lot of overhead was added for security. Now you need ID to get into a lot of places you did not need before. For example: my uncle was a UPS driver, and he said before 9/11 people just saw the uniform and waved him through. Bottom line, I think 9/11 showed there was no slack capacity, and a lot of companies struggled. I guess companies just adjusted to the new reality.

I do remember reading articles/web pages questioning JIT, and stating that if there was more slack capacity adjusting would have been easier, although I cannot think of any specific URLs/writers at the moment.

I am just a software grunt, but I feel like I have seen a similar dynamic in every job/project I have been on. Management keeps yacking about innovation, and pushing more work on us, while dismissing the notion that more time and/or more people would make everyone's lives a lot easier.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse