undefined | Better HN

0 pointsjongjong3y ago0 comments

I wouldn't say that you need to reinvent any framework. I was able to build a simple application using HTMLElement directly. I just had to define a handful of utility functions to do things like escape HTML tags for user-generated content... The main critique I can think of is that Web Components provide many ways to do things; for example, you can create elements using vanilla JS or using template strings (or even a combination of both)... When it comes to event handlers; you can also define them using vanilla JS or inline inside the tags as part of the template string (or both). There is no single standard way to do anything so that was the real challenge but this can easily be solved through project-based coding style guidelines. There aren't that many gotchas.

0 comments

dmitriid3y ago

> I wouldn't say that you need to reinvent any framework.

You do, when you need at least slightly more complex.

> The main critique I can think of is that Web Components provide many ways to do things

Nope. The main critique is that Web Components is 2010s tech solidified in the platform when the rest of the world has moved on and is now exploring fine-grained reactivity and trying to remove components as a unit of work/ui. That they are 12 years in the making and still have issues that no framework has (see links here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34346269). That their design now poisons the rest of the platform that needs to add countless new workarounds for their shortcomings, and seemingly unrelated standards (like scoped CSS) now have to take them into consideration...

Well, there is not just one main critique, there are many main critiques

> There aren't that many gotchas.

Just because you haven't run into them it doesn't mean there aren't any gotchas. And there are plenty.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse