undefined | Better HN

0 pointsfiloleg3y ago0 comments

> If I upload a podcast to Apple, it's physically inaccessible unless you have a Mac or an iOS device.

Unless I am misunderstanding your claim, this is not true.

You can listen to Apple Podcasts using iTunes for Windows. You can also listen to them on Android. But dealing with it on Android is indeed annoying, because it requires downloading podcasts in itunes on your desktop, and then manually transferring them to your Android phone after finding the locally stored files.

However, it is easy to sidestep all of that if the podcast creator just uploads to multiple podcast hosting platforms.

0 comments

makeitdouble3y ago

> requires downloading podcasts in itunes on your desktop, and then manually transferring them to your Android phone after finding the locally stored files.

TFA says they're DRMed, are they still readable on a random android client just by moving the files ?

filolegOP3y ago

That part of TFA confused me as well, because I just tested it out on my Win10 desktop, and it worked effortlessly.

I didn't even have to search for the local files. iTunes had a nice "Show in Windows Explorer" button next to the episode I downloaded, which opened a directory with the mp3 audio file for the episode (neatly tagged and named and all). I opened it with VLC and confirmed that the playback works perfectly fine.

Disclaimer: I haven't tested the part with transferring the file to an Android device specifically. But if an mp3 audio file plays fine in any third-party media player on Windows, I think it is safe to assume that it would play fine on Android as well.

bastawhiz3y ago

Here's an example show, I'm curious if it works for you: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

1 more reply

tcarn3y ago

Wow, this is a great workaround then to the author's issue.

2 more replies

bastawhiz3y ago

You cannot download these podcast episodes as a file because they are protected with DRM. Seriously, find one of these shows and try getting a file from it

filolegOP3y ago

Are all podcasts protected this way or just some specific ones? Because I picked a random one from the front page of the podcast section in iTunes on Win10, and it worked for me with zero issues[0].

If you can find a podcast on Apple Podcasts for which the method I described in my other comment doesn't work, please post it here. Because it would feel kinda strange if Podcasts app applied DRM like this only to some specific podcasts and not all of them.

0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34524966

bastawhiz3y ago

No: this isn't just any random podcast from the iTunes homepage. It only applies to podcasts which are hosted by Apple, not ones which Apple lists in its directory. This is a very small percentage of shows.

Here is an example. Curious if you can get it to work on Windows, because I physically cannot save the audio to a normal file on Mac. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

1 more reply

tshaddox3y ago

You can also listen to it on the Apple Podcasts website, e.g. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-daily/id1200361736...

bastawhiz3y ago

The podcasts in question can't be played in the browser. It always forces you to open Apple Podcasts.

Here's an example: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsfiloleg3y ago0 comments

> If I upload a podcast to Apple, it's physically inaccessible unless you have a Mac or an iOS device.

Unless I am misunderstanding your claim, this is not true.

However, it is easy to sidestep all of that if the podcast creator just uploads to multiple podcast hosting platforms.

0 comments

makeitdouble3y ago

> requires downloading podcasts in itunes on your desktop, and then manually transferring them to your Android phone after finding the locally stored files.

TFA says they're DRMed, are they still readable on a random android client just by moving the files ?

filolegOP3y ago

That part of TFA confused me as well, because I just tested it out on my Win10 desktop, and it worked effortlessly.

bastawhiz3y ago

Here's an example show, I'm curious if it works for you: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

1 more reply

tcarn3y ago

Wow, this is a great workaround then to the author's issue.

2 more replies

bastawhiz3y ago

You cannot download these podcast episodes as a file because they are protected with DRM. Seriously, find one of these shows and try getting a file from it

filolegOP3y ago

Are all podcasts protected this way or just some specific ones? Because I picked a random one from the front page of the podcast section in iTunes on Win10, and it worked for me with zero issues[0].

0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34524966

bastawhiz3y ago

Here is an example. Curious if you can get it to work on Windows, because I physically cannot save the audio to a normal file on Mac. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

1 more reply

tshaddox3y ago

You can also listen to it on the Apple Podcasts website, e.g. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-daily/id1200361736...

bastawhiz3y ago

The podcasts in question can't be played in the browser. It always forces you to open Apple Podcasts.

Here's an example: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/test-podcast/id1667708...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse