Let's say you start with brand new tires on both wheels. Let's further suppose that you completely wear out your rear tire in 1 year and your front tire in 4 years. If on the first anniversary you rotate and place the new tire in front, you'll need to repeat the procedure after 9 months, and then every 9 months after that. On the 4th anniversary you'll have bought 5 tires: on the 12th, 21st, 30th, 39th, and 48th months. If you simply replace each tire as it wears out without any rotation, on the 4th year you'll have bought 5 tires, 1 to replace the front tire once and 4 to replace the rear tire 4 times.