Skip to content

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Show HN: DigicamFinder – open-sourced DPReview camera data (opens in new tab)

(digicamfinder.com)

177 pointspetergreen2y ago29 comments

Ever since the DPReview closure announcement https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35248296 we were thinking how to preserve the 25 years of valuable DPReview camera data. Archive.org has been great, but it's not usable by the general public.

The best way to keep it safe going forward, is to have the community own it, so we open sourced it: https://github.com/open-product-data/digital-cameras

I'm aware of a number of attempts to make product data open-sourced, but none have the power of the photo geeks behind it :)

Thoughts or ideas? + really looking for some contribution love.

Show HN: DigicamFinder – open-sourced DPReview camera data | Better HN

29 comments

codersfocus2y ago

Wow, did you get this up in the 10 day time period since they announced closure? It took me 2 months for my project.

I think I should really look into just scraping / importing the lens data at this point for cameralenspicker.com. I’ve been hand inputting the data… but it’s just too slow.

petergreenOP2y ago

We really had to step on the gas with this one. There has been just so much reverberations in the photo community that it became clear that it needs to be done (and quick).

This is a great effort! But yes, manual adding is slow, so the way is likely to crowdsource/automate it.

blagie2y ago

The trick here would be to do a static scrape of all of dpreview, and post it on archive.org or similar. It's copyrighted, but I can't imagine enforcement of a discontinued resource.

Amazon is imploding a huge amount of value here.

petergreenOP2y ago

it's already on Archive.org https://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/11zucov/dprevi...

but it's super slow and hard for the general public to access, and many JS features won't work.

appleflaxen2y ago

This is just awesome. DPReview has been the gold standard for digital cameras and I am heartbroken to see it close. Thank you for performing such an incredibly generous act with the DPReview data.

dn35002y ago

What's the copyright status? The specs you have on there now should be fine, you can't copyright lists of facts. But if you put the reviews up will Amazon come after you?

petergreenOP2y ago

That's why we're linking to reviews for now, instead of pulling them in.

One way is to summarize DPR member reviews with GPT4 and keep just the summary / score up.

Ultimately we want to make an awesome review tool on top of this data and start collecting original reviews.

Lammy2y ago

> But if you put the reviews up will Amazon come after you?

That would be the best possible PR for this project lol

RobotToaster2y ago

Once they delete it, they would have to use the internet archive to prove they own it, which would be rather ironic.

ulnarkressty2y ago

Are the plans for a comparison feature? This was invaluable when trying to figure out what changed in various versions of the same camera family.

mg2y ago

I run Product Chart which has a camera chart that lets you select two cameras and compare them:

https://www.productchart.com/cameras

Select "highlight" on the first camera you want to compare and then when you hover over the second, select "Compare to ..."

Does that work for you?

We have manually researched the product data for over 45,000 products. At the moment we only show currently popular cameras on the chart. But if there is demand, I could add a search for older cameras so those can be compared as well.

petergreenOP2y ago

That is an awesome project!

petergreenOP2y ago

interesting, thank you for the insight on the use case. yes, this is fairly easy to implement.

_gtly2y ago

Nice work! Wish there was a site that held information on more than just cameras - expanded to all types of electronics, for instance.. seeing all the hardware from a manufacturer over time is so useful for making buying decisions.

EDIT: Ah cool, I see this: "OPD plans to expand our dataset to other product types." source: https://github.com/open-product-data/digital-cameras/commit/...

petergreenOP2y ago

Exactly! :) The lenses are coming next, but if there are requests for specific categories of things that would be interesting, we're all ears!

We're thinking gadgets, cars, music equipment would be a good start.

Great stuff! Curious if you plan on integrating some of the existing dpreview user reviews and Q&A. I have found those to be quite helpful as well. Also, the sample galleries might be too much to ask for given the storage requirements but wanted to see if this is part of future plans as well.

petergreenOP2y ago

We're considering both, but mainly listening to the "community voice" right now :)

Linking to data on other sites (including archive.org) seems like a better way to go, than pulling everything in (as you mentioned, storage reqs become a challenge fairly quickly)

All I can say is: well done and thank you!

> If you do anything with photography, you probably know that Amazon, being Amazon, is shutting down DPReview.com, which housed some of the most complete data and knowledge related to digital cameras online.

Amazon also owns IMDB. I hope someone is making backups ...

stanac2y ago

> Amazon also owns IMDB. I hope someone is making backups ...

Yes, but they use IMDB to sell amazon prime. Same thing with goodreads, they use it to sell books on amazon.

Hasnep2y ago

Did they use DPReview to sell cameras? I imagine they did, but I hadn't heard of it until today so I'm not sure.

zvr2y ago

That is a great project!

Do you plan to enhance the UI, for example to be able to filter by other data, like zoom or weight?

Or are you more interested in the data and prefer others to build other websites on top of them?

petergreenOP2y ago

Absolutely - we're adding the rest of the filters next. Just had to cut scope in order to launch in shorter time

status2002y ago

Impressive that it was only a two day period between the shutdown announcement and the first version of DigicamFinder going up - well done to all those involved.

LoulouMonkey2y ago

I used to love this website, and remember using it almost 20 years ago to purchase an Olympus c-5060.

Great work!

voltaireodactyl2y ago

Thank you for making this happen, such a critical website.

damn, i literally just now created a DPReview account so I could join a discussion on NX1 hacking...had no idea they were shutting down

alokym2y ago

Good job

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse