undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbob10292y ago0 comments

> I'll bet modern engineered speakers will beat those high quality speakers, at a fraction of the price.

You'd be surprised how shitty most "modern" speakers are.

Size is still king. Doesn't matter how fast your fancy microcontrollers are. The big-ass cabinets from the 80s and 90s still sound incredible when you put them next to the typical experience you'd find on the shelves of Target or Best Buy.

0 comments

bombcar2y ago

Correct. The only downside on some of those large speakers is the paper cones can get brittle and break, but when properly repaired they sound great.

Often the woofer on the speaker is larger than a modern 5.1 subwoofer.

hakfoo2y ago

The one argument I can see for modern speakers is materials: theoretically we can have better materials science-- better foams and rubbers for the gaskets and such, better insulating batting.

However, it is frustrating that I can't get modern speakers anything like my parents' three-ways with a 12 or 15 inch woofer without finding some esoteric offering.

bob1029OP2y ago

> However, it is frustrating that I can't get modern speakers anything like my parents' three-ways with a 12 or 15 inch woofer without finding some esoteric offering.

You can get "modern" builds of the very same loudspeakers right now with major brands like Klipsch - https://www.klipsch.com/heritage-premium-audio The AK6 is still considered by many to be the best loudspeaker you can ever own.

ghaff2y ago

Yeah, I'd probably ditch the big stereo system if I were starting over from scratch at this point. But that would be in the interests of downsizing, not because I have any illusions that a soundbar is as good as my surround sound setup with large speakers and a subwoofer.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse