undefined | Better HN

0 pointsPDTao5Q2TMaTp7U2y ago0 comments

That's a disingenuous comparison. PCIe is not USB-C. You are comparing apples to oranges.

The Framework laptop expansion cards are all USB-C dongles in a different form factor. It's purely an esthetic choice. You don't like the dangle. Thats a valid opinion. I have a USB-C hub that handles all the connections I need in a dongle-dangle.

The only real objective benefit of it, IMO, (and this is HUGE) is the repairability. I am a huge fan of that, and hope that other makes would step up (or be forced to step up) and make the same kind of changes.

0 comments

rcoveson2y ago

An expansion card that is flush with the rest of the laptop frame compared to a dongle that dangles from the side is absolutely not just an aesthetic difference. Expansion cards don't need to be disconnected and reconnected whenever you move the laptop. Dongles do. You can't put a laptop with four dongles hanging off of it into a bag.

The distinction between USB-C and PCIe, on the other hand, is meaningless for most peripherals.

An imaginary handheld AM radio is more similar to a handheld FM radio than the handheld FM radio is to a desktop FM radio, from the user's perspective. You could say that "comparing AM to FM is apples to oranges", but the user wouldn't care as much as they care about how they actually interact with the thing.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsPDTao5Q2TMaTp7U2y ago0 comments

That's a disingenuous comparison. PCIe is not USB-C. You are comparing apples to oranges.

0 comments

rcoveson2y ago

The distinction between USB-C and PCIe, on the other hand, is meaningless for most peripherals.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse