undefined | Better HN

0 pointssnowwrestler2y ago0 comments

Yes but what you don’t see is the many many requests in the same tone that come into social media (and traditional media!) companies from corporations, celebrities, even regular old citizens who are mad their drunk driving arrest got reported (for example).

The idea that an imperious tone somehow proves a power imbalance is hilarious to anyone who has ever been on the receiving end of these requests from regular people. “I demand an answer right now” is what angry diners say when a restaurant runs of the special. It’s the tone that people adopt to imply power when they don’t actually have power, but want to seem like they do. Which is a common, and legal, mode of speaking in everyday life.

0 comments

uLogMicheal2y ago

This is not talking about "regular old citizens". This is the government and the government has power. Your comment is basically a Straw man.

joshuamorton2y ago

No, the point of the comment is that the government didn't have power in this situation.

mrguyorama2y ago

The government has power. Craig the office drone asking for "misinformation" to be taken down at behest of his boss does not have the power "The government" does.

Or am I now supposed to believe that if you anger Sheila at the DMV the IRS will audit you?

melony2y ago

> The government has power. Craig the office drone asking for "misinformation" to be taken down at behest of his boss does not have the power "The government" does. Or am I now supposed to believe that if you anger Sheila at the DMV the IRS will audit you?

Craig's boss is the highest executive power in the country. Most of their work is handled by aides and subordinates like Craig, with authority delegated from their office. The boss only directly makes the important decisions. You are being disingenuous by claiming Craig is a innocent, powerless trigger-happy drone. And if you have lived in small towns, expect to receive worse service or discrimination from Sheila in future. The highest power in the country cannot be held to the same standard as a county clerk (and frankly speaking, most DMV employees need more training in customer service and have their compensation tied to overall productivity and performance, lots of fat to be trimmed there, both literal and metaphorical).

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse