undefined | Better HN

0 pointsnottorp2y ago0 comments

> The problem is that the computing industry has changed.

Nah, the problem is ipv6 has been designed by a commitee for a lot of enterprise-ish features so the hobbyists have taken a look and postponed setting it up internally for when they have absolutely no choice.

I've asked for simple ipv6 tutorials in discussions on HN and elsewhere and whatever I got pointed at was always longer than the article we're discussing and incomplete.

Basic set up of ipv4 for a home network can be explained over just one pint. Looks like you need two barrells for ipv6.

0 comments

yesco2y ago

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6/configurati...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/routing/examples...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6_ipv4_transi...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6/ipv6_extras

nottorpOP2y ago

Yeah right. The summary of the first page already throws around like 4-5 acronyms that each require reading a separate documentation.

And that's only for configuring your router, not your local network...

yesco2y ago

Okay then please provide me the level of documentation you are looking for, but for an IPv4 network. Sounds wonderful, I'd love to share it with new hires.

JohnFen2y ago

> I've asked for simple ipv6 tutorials

There really does seem to be a lack of good documentation about all of this. The docs that I've seen appear to be aimed at actual network engineers, or are so incomplete as to not be worthwhile.

I would be much less stressed by all of this if I could find something good that sits between those two extremes.

A part of me, though, suspects that the reason there is no "middle ground" documentation is that it's not possible -- that IPv6 is too complex for that. Not saying that's the actual reality, but it has the whiff of it.

yesco2y ago

All networking is complex.

I asked the other guy this, but I'll also ask you. Please provide me the level of documentation you are looking for, but for an IPv4 network. If you have some grand tutorial that explains it as easily as you make it out to be, then I truly would love to see it, I will include it in my onboarding documentation at work.

Because I understand both IPv4 and IPv6, and do not consider IPv6 the more complex protocol by any measure. I suspect your "whiff" is more a bias towards what you are comfortable with, rather than a true reflection of IPv6's complexity.

nottorpOP2y ago

> Because I understand both IPv4 and IPv6, and do not consider IPv6 the more complex protocol by any measure.

You mentioned "new hires" while i mentioned hobbyists. You're talking about a business network where people are paid to do it, I'm talking about home networks and home labs.

You're basically confirming my statement that IPv6 was designed for enterprise needs?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsnottorp2y ago0 comments

> The problem is that the computing industry has changed.

I've asked for simple ipv6 tutorials in discussions on HN and elsewhere and whatever I got pointed at was always longer than the article we're discussing and incomplete.

Basic set up of ipv4 for a home network can be explained over just one pint. Looks like you need two barrells for ipv6.

0 comments

yesco2y ago

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6/configurati...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/routing/examples...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6_ipv4_transi...

- https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/ipv6/ipv6_extras

nottorpOP2y ago

Yeah right. The summary of the first page already throws around like 4-5 acronyms that each require reading a separate documentation.

And that's only for configuring your router, not your local network...

yesco2y ago

Okay then please provide me the level of documentation you are looking for, but for an IPv4 network. Sounds wonderful, I'd love to share it with new hires.

JohnFen2y ago

> I've asked for simple ipv6 tutorials

There really does seem to be a lack of good documentation about all of this. The docs that I've seen appear to be aimed at actual network engineers, or are so incomplete as to not be worthwhile.

I would be much less stressed by all of this if I could find something good that sits between those two extremes.

yesco2y ago

All networking is complex.

nottorpOP2y ago

> Because I understand both IPv4 and IPv6, and do not consider IPv6 the more complex protocol by any measure.

You mentioned "new hires" while i mentioned hobbyists. You're talking about a business network where people are paid to do it, I'm talking about home networks and home labs.

You're basically confirming my statement that IPv6 was designed for enterprise needs?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse