undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgustavus2y ago0 comments

I'm sure China and Russia and Iran and all those other nations will 100% see the value of artificially restricting their AI efforts as well because of the risk of harm, and be socially responsible global citizens, that won't exploit this edge for thier own geopolitical agenda.

0 comments

cscurmudgeon2y ago

And when these countries overtake the US, the same people who brought AI regulations in the US will cry foul could when we regulate AI products from overseas.

vsareto2y ago

I doubt any military or strategically important applications will be regulated

sterlind2y ago

That sounds like the worst of all worlds. Killer robots and childproofed Alexas and nothing in between.

naveen992y ago

They’ll probably use ai to build an alternative to microsoft windows and Active Directory to start with. Interestingly microsoft makes just 2% of its revenue from china, despite an 85% market share for personal computer operating systems there. But I am sure China would prefer to not deal with windows telemetry also.

jprete2y ago

China’s government is extremely interested in restricting their AI efforts because they don’t want it to contradict the Communist party.

__loam2y ago

Yeah people bringing up China as if it's some bastion of freedom in comparison to us are hilarious.

gustavusOP2y ago

Soviet man and American man were arguing about which country was more free.

The American man said "I am so free I could walk up to the White house right now and scream 'I hate Ronald Reagan he is an incompetent buffoon.' Without getting arrested."

The Russian man responded "That is not any more free than me I too could walk up to the Kremlin and scream 'I hate Ronald Reagan he is an incompetent buffoon.' without getting in any trouble."

cscurmudgeon2y ago

No one did that. That is a straw man. People are less free but govt and institutions aligned with govt are more free.

qualifiedai2y ago

But they are doing it in a way that do not hinder their fundamentals - they are enforcing that on alignment (see Baichuan2-chat) and application levels.

Unlike Biden's silly EO which puts restrictions on foundation model compute levels.

startupsfail2y ago

The party is under the authority of its ‘forever’ president Xi Jingping, a good friend of another dully elected president - Putin.

And the interest is: “whatever is on the mind of an aging, non-elected dictator and his favorites”.

petre2y ago

If you think the US is going to restrict its AI efforts, you are mistaken. This is just a big tech lobbying circus. They'll happily sell Uncle Sam robotic dogs with RPGs and targeting computers, autonomous drone swarms and other AI enabed hardware to deploy across all operations theatres.

The Chinese are busy studying “Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era", the Russians are busy getting wasted in Ukraine and the Iranians are busy checking if women are properly wearing their hijabs and smuggling weapons into Gaza.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

cscurmudgeon2y ago

And when these countries overtake the US, the same people who brought AI regulations in the US will cry foul could when we regulate AI products from overseas.

vsareto2y ago

I doubt any military or strategically important applications will be regulated

sterlind2y ago

That sounds like the worst of all worlds. Killer robots and childproofed Alexas and nothing in between.

naveen992y ago

jprete2y ago

China’s government is extremely interested in restricting their AI efforts because they don’t want it to contradict the Communist party.

__loam2y ago

Yeah people bringing up China as if it's some bastion of freedom in comparison to us are hilarious.

gustavusOP2y ago

Soviet man and American man were arguing about which country was more free.

The American man said "I am so free I could walk up to the White house right now and scream 'I hate Ronald Reagan he is an incompetent buffoon.' Without getting arrested."

The Russian man responded "That is not any more free than me I too could walk up to the Kremlin and scream 'I hate Ronald Reagan he is an incompetent buffoon.' without getting in any trouble."

cscurmudgeon2y ago

No one did that. That is a straw man. People are less free but govt and institutions aligned with govt are more free.

qualifiedai2y ago

But they are doing it in a way that do not hinder their fundamentals - they are enforcing that on alignment (see Baichuan2-chat) and application levels.

Unlike Biden's silly EO which puts restrictions on foundation model compute levels.

startupsfail2y ago

The party is under the authority of its ‘forever’ president Xi Jingping, a good friend of another dully elected president - Putin.

And the interest is: “whatever is on the mind of an aging, non-elected dictator and his favorites”.

petre2y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse