Shadow Bans Only Fool Humans, Not Bots (opens in new tab)

It was in the official docs:

> Often, it may be advantageous to shadowban a troll or spammer rather than ban them - an actual ban simply tells them that it's time to create a new account. With a shadowban, they don't know they've been banned. [1]

They've since renamed that to a "bot ban", but the effect is the same. Anyway, all comment removals on Reddit are shadow banned by default. You can try it yourself by commenting in r/CantSayAnything [2]. Your comment will be removed, you won't receive any notification, and it will still appear to you as if it's not removed.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/AutoModerator/wiki/library?v=acf57c...

[2] https://old.reddit.com/r/CantSayAnything/about/sticky

With automod rules you can set it up so a user's posts are filtered (hidden for everyone else), and then never review the posts to approve/fully delete them.

It's accurate. Comment shows up to the user, doesn't show up to everyone else. I wrote some code for someone where it alerts them if a comment they post is shadowbanned (compares their comment/post history to what others can see). Might scale it up when time permits with a browser extension.